# A Million Miles, One Healthy Goat, and a Little IVF 101
Over the past week, we’ve driven from Mishicot, WI, to Naperville, IL (~4 hours), back to Mishicot, over to Madison, WI (~3 hours), back to Mishicot, back to Madison, and back and forth between Mishicot and Naperville pretty much every single day.
We’re still exhausted and completely over being in the car, BUT during one of those trips, we finally got some good news!
Vani, our abscess → hernia → surgery → suture rejection → infection doeling, has officially been cleared by the vets at UW–Madison! Very unexpectedly, they even gave us the green light for future breeding. We’ll see how she grows and develops over the next year before we decide whether we actually want to put her through that, but after everything she’s been through, it’s really nice to finally have a little good news!
So, Why All the Trips to Naperville?
After the miracle worker who is Dr. Charles Miller attempted a repair of Jess’ uterus, we decided to try another 1–2 egg retrievals before we officially age out of the process. We already have three euploid (chromosomally normal) embryos and one high-level mosaic embryo frozen from previous retrievals, but at 41 years old, we know our chances of making more are only getting slimmer. We’re hoping to give ourselves the best possible chance of eventually bringing home a baby!
For some reason, Facebook’s algorithm has also decided that what we really need to see right now is a steady stream of anti-IVF posts. A lot of the arguments we’ve come across don’t seem to reflect much understanding of how IVF actually works, so we thought we’d share what the process looks like and why we don’t believe it conflicts with our faith.
Is IVF “Playing God”?
One of the arguments we keep seeing is that IVF is “playing God.” We don’t agree. To us, using IVF to help overcome infertility is no more an attempt to replace God than treating cancer, performing heart surgery, or giving a premature baby medical assistance.
We believe God gave us the ability to learn, discover, and develop medicine. IVF works with the same eggs, sperm, chromosomes, and biological processes involved in natural conception. Doctors can use medication to encourage follicles to grow, retrieve eggs, help fertilization occur, and provide an environment for embryos to develop. What they can’t do is guarantee that any of it will actually work.
They can’t force an egg to fertilize, an embryo to continue developing, or a pregnancy to survive. Believe us, if doctors had that kind of control, our journey would have looked very different!
We believe God is still very much involved in all of those steps, and that using the medical knowledge available to us doesn’t somehow remove Him from the process. Medicine can help overcome some of the obstacles to conception, but there’s still an enormous amount that neither doctors nor patients can control.
How IVF Actually Works
IVF starts with ovarian stimulation and egg retrieval. For about 1–2 weeks, the woman injects herself with medications every day. In Jess’ case, that meant somewhere around 5–7 shots per day, all in the abdomen. Super fun!
Normally, the body recruits a group of follicles but ultimately selects one dominant follicle to mature and ovulate. IVF medications attempt to keep more of those follicles growing at the same time, with the goal of retrieving several mature eggs instead of the single egg that would typically ovulate during a natural cycle. The number that actually responds depends heavily on age, ovarian reserve, general health, and the medication protocol.
This time around, Jess started with roughly 11 follicles. There are a ton of different IVF protocols, and this particular one may not have been the best match for her. One follicle became dominant very quickly while the others lagged behind, and that lead follicle either ovulated or popped before retrieval. But eventually, five eggs were retrieved from the remaining follicles.
Despite all the medications, monitoring appointments, and adjustments, that’s what her body gave us. It’s a pretty good example of just how much of this process still happens on its own terms!
Of those five eggs, only two were mature enough to be fertilized immediately. Dr. Miller’s state-of-the-art lab was able to mature two additional eggs in vitro, and one of those was successfully fertilized as well.
So we went from roughly 11 follicles to five retrieved eggs to three fertilized eggs.
That’s another thing we think people misunderstand about IVF. Having five eggs retrieved doesn’t mean you have five future babies, or even five embryos that can eventually be transferred. Fertilization is only one step in a fairly long process, and most fertilized eggs stop developing before they reach the blastocyst stage, which takes 4–7 days.
Our three are currently growing in the lab, and in about five more days we’ll find out whether any of them made it that far. We could end up with three blastocysts, one, or none. There’s simply no way to know yet, no matter how good the lab is or how much we want them to keep growing.
Genetic Testing and the Ethical Questions
If we’re lucky enough to get a blastocyst, the next step for us will be PGT-A testing. This is where we think some of the more legitimate ethical questions surrounding IVF come into play, and different countries have different rules about how it’s used.
PGT-A stands for preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy. A few cells are biopsied from the part of the embryo that will develop into the placenta, and those cells are tested to estimate whether the embryo has the expected number of chromosomes. Testing can also reveal chromosomal sex, although that’s not why we’re doing it.
Chromosomal abnormalities are a major reason pregnancies fail, especially early in development, and they become increasingly common as women age. Many fertilized eggs never implant at all, and others result in miscarriages. PGT-A attempts to identify embryos that appear euploid (chromosomally normal) before transferring them.
It’s not foolproof, though. The biopsy only tests a handful of cells, and sometimes different parts of an embryo have different chromosomal findings, a condition called mosaicism. An abnormal result doesn’t necessarily mean every cell is abnormal or that the embryo is incapable of self-correcting and producing a healthy baby. On the other hand, even an embryo that tests perfectly normal can still fail to implant or miscarry. PGT-A also hasn’t been shown to improve live-birth rates for every patient, so its usefulness depends on individual circumstances.
After 3+ miscarriages, our doctors have all recommended PGT-A for us. At this point, we’d rather have whatever additional information we can get before putting Jess’ body through another pregnancy and potentially another loss, while understanding that the results aren’t guarantees.
But Doesn’t IVF “Murder Babies”?
This is probably the most common argument we’ve seen against IVF: that embryos are children, and IVF involves creating them only to destroy them.
We think there’s an important distinction being missed here between embryos that stop developing on their own and embryos that are intentionally discarded. Most fertilized eggs never develop into blastocysts, even under ideal laboratory conditions. The same thing happens during natural reproduction – except most women never know fertilization occurred in the first place.
With IVF, we’re able to observe some of that early development in a lab. If one of our three fertilized eggs stops growing tomorrow, it won’t be because somebody killed it. It’ll be because it stopped developing despite our doctors doing everything they could to support it. That’s heartbreaking when you’re desperately hoping for a child, but it isn’t an intentional act of destruction.
Of course, there are circumstances in IVF where embryos are intentionally discarded, including when families have completed treatment or following certain genetic testing results. We understand why someone who believes every embryo has the same moral status as a born child would object to those decisions. We’re not suggesting those concerns aren’t worth discussing, but they aren’t an unavoidable part of every IVF journey, either.
Something that rarely seems to come up in these discussions is embryo donation, sometimes called embryo adoption. Families who have completed IVF and have embryos remaining can choose to donate them to other people who are unable to conceive using their own eggs or sperm, or who have otherwise struggled to build a family.
The receiving mother can have a donated embryo transferred into her uterus and, if it implants successfully, carry and give birth to a baby who isn’t genetically related to her. It’s an incredible option for people who might otherwise never have the opportunity to experience pregnancy or childbirth.
Donation isn’t a perfect or simple solution for every situation, and of course there are legal, medical, and emotional considerations involved. But if the concern is that embryos are being created only to be discarded, it’s worth acknowledging that families have other options, including keeping embryos frozen or donating them to someone else who hopes to have a child.
We also think it’s important to understand that IVF doesn’t involve routinely sacrificing embryos to make one successful baby. Even with a euploid embryo, a single transfer only has around a 50–60% chance of resulting in a live birth, depending on individual circumstances. That’s why fertility specialists sometimes discuss trying to obtain around three euploid embryos to give a family a strong cumulative chance of having one child.
That doesn’t mean three embryos are required to produce one baby, or that two have to be destroyed for the third to survive. Embryos are generally transferred one at a time. Some people have a baby after their first transfer, while others need several attempts, and unfortunately some never succeed even with embryos that appear chromosomally normal.
We have three euploid embryos and one high-level mosaic embryo frozen from previous retrievals, which we’re incredibly thankful for! But even having three euploid embryos doesn’t guarantee we’ll bring home a baby. With Jess’ history of recurrent miscarriages and uterine abnormalities, we’re understandably nervous about putting all our hopes into the embryos we already have.
That’s why we’re trying to do another retrieval or two now, while we still have the opportunity. We can work on preparing for embryo transfers afterward, but we can’t turn back the clock on egg quality.
And Then There’s the Actual Pregnancy…
When we’re finally able to move forward with an embryo transfer, we’ll first need to prepare the uterus and uterine lining. That means another round of medications – more injections in the abdomen and he butt muscle, pills, patches, and suppositories. It’s a good thing that Jess got over her fear of shots!
Once everything is ready, an embryo is transferred into the uterus, and then we get to wait some more! It still has to implant, continue developing, establish a heartbeat, and make it through all the same pregnancy milestones as a naturally conceived baby.
And as we’ve unfortunately learned multiple times, becoming pregnant and bringing home a baby are two very different things.
Faith, Medicine, and a Little Hope
We’re not expecting everyone to agree with us about IVF. There are genuine religious and ethical disagreements about the moral status of embryos, genetic testing, and how embryos should be handled, and we understand why those things matter to people.
What we disagree with is the idea that simply seeking medical help to conceive means we’re trying to replace God or that we somehow don’t trust Him.
We believe God gave people the intelligence and ability to develop medicine, and that He can work through the doctors, nurses, and embryologists who dedicate their lives to helping others. We also believe He remains involved in the process regardless of how conception occurs. IVF can help us overcome some of the biological obstacles we’ve encountered, but it doesn’t give us the power to create a successful pregnancy whenever we want one.
We’ve already experienced the heartbreak of naturally conceived pregnancies ending in miscarriage. We know better than most that conception doesn’t guarantee a living baby, and IVF certainly hasn’t changed that reality. It’s simply given us another opportunity to try.
We’re not trying to replace God in the process of creating a family. We’re using the medical help available to us while trusting Him with the outcome.
If IVF really gave humans God’s power over creating life, we’d probably have a lot more to show for all these appointments, injections, procedures, and insaneeee bills! Instead, we have three euploid embryos and one high-level mosaic waiting in the freezer, three newly fertilized eggs growing in a lab in Naperville, a team of very talented doctors, and absolutely no guarantee that any of this will result in a baby.
We’re incredibly grateful for the embryos we already have, and we’re hoping and praying that at least one of our three new little contenders keeps growing, too.
So that’s been our week: several thousand miles on the road, more needles than we care to count, three fertilized eggs, and one goat who has decided she’s finally done funding the UW veterinary program.
We’re exhausted, sick of driving, and would be perfectly happy not to see another stretch of Chicago construction for a while. But at least Vani finally got her clean bill of health, and we’re hoping Jess’ reproductive system might eventually follow her lead.
Although, given how much the two of them seem to enjoy keeping medical specialists employed, we’re not holding our breath.



